By Ron Borges
The Boston Herald’s all-time greatest Patriot on-line poll continues and it is down to 32 players after the first round of eliminations. Most of the results have thus far been predictable and, as I look at my bracket, the only way it doesn’t come out as Tom Brady vs. Andre Tippett in the final is if enough nitwits with computers and no sense that the game was ever played prior to the year 2000 takes Tippett out in favor of, say, Richard Seymour, who is also in his bracket (and up against top tackle Bruce Armstrong this round).
One interesting match up this week is the one between Drew Bledsoe and Ted Johnson. As beloved as Johnson is, there’s no question Bledsoe meant more to the organization and, at his best, was the superior player at his position. The historical fact is if Bledsoe had not come along when he did, the Patriots would have won all these Super Bowl championships elsewhere, probably in
If, as I expect, it comes down to Brady vs. Tippett (after a Tippett vs.
The fact is Tippett was a Hall-of-Fame quality linebacker (member of the 1980 All-Decade team and a finalist for the Hall a year ago) who should become the team’s second player to reach
Brady, too, is headed for Canton five years after his retirement even if he retired this morning so what it will come down to when fans look to name what the Herald is calling “The Greatest Patriots Player of All-Time’’ are two things – offense vs. defense and the moment vs. 20 years ago.
In the end we all know it’s going to be Tom Brady and, outside of Tippett’s friends and immediate family, who could argue with that? No one but those people who believe, and so often say, that defense wins championships. If they buy into that it could make for a closer vote than expected.
To vote go to bostonherald.com but no stuffing the internet ballot box.


3 responses so far ↓
1 Sundayjack // Jan 23, 2008 at 3:39 pm
Hey Ron - I feel compelled to write something in anticipation of the upcoming Pro Football Hall of Fame selection and, of course, your presentation on behalf of Andre Tippett. Oddly enough, I’m a Jets fan, so I’d just as soon see Joe Klecko elected, but for one simple fact - Tip is a friend, and I’d like nothing more than to see him honored.
I’ve heard you speak of him glowingly in the past, and I’ve certainly appreciated seeing that. I guess the point of this is, if nothing else, to soothe my own sense of urgency. I know that each year he goes unselected, he’s one year further away from selection, with fading memories and new crops of candidates. If this one gets done, I can go back to resenting all-things-Patriot with vigor.
Thanks,
- SJ
2 Ron Borges // Jan 24, 2008 at 8:28 pm
SJ - I think Tippett has a well-deserved solid shot to make it this yer. It’s his second straight year as a finalist and the voters got to know more about him. He made the final 10 but there were four “pass rushers” among them and I think they cancelled each other out. the fact he was just named to the All-Time 3-4 front in Pro Football Weekly should help his chances as well.
3 tmackie // Aug 5, 2008 at 10:26 am
Why doesn’t the HOF consider great players who didn’t play on great teams? Take a guy like Floyd Little of the Broncos. He played on one of the worst AFL/AFC teams for years. He was the team’s lone star yet, even after entering the league as a 25-year-old rookie, he retired 7th all-time in NFL history. He led the AFC and NFL in rushing, and from 1968-73, he accrued more yards rushing and more yards from scrimmage than any player. He was “The Franchise” of the Denver Broncos who laid the foundation and kept the team in Denver when they were about to move to Birmingham or Chicago. He’s the reason the Broncos are one of the marquee teams they are today.
Ron, your take?
You must log in to post a comment.